Your Window Improvements May Vary

I love my new job. This morning I’m sitting in a training session organized by the SQL Server team to bring Microsoft team members up to speed on new Business Intelligence capabilities in SQL Server “Denali”. The session is about to begin, and I’m reviewing the SSIS slides so I can be prepared for questions as they arise. (Did I mention I love my new job?)

I also love ambiguity.[1]

One of the features listed in the presentation is “Variable Window Improvements”. Reading this, all I could think is “we’ve really improved the windows, but they’re different all the time, so we can’t tell you what they are.”[2]

Of course, that’s not what the slide was about. The topic was the specific improvements made to the Variables Window for the SSIS package designer in SQL Server “Denali” Business Intelligence Development Studio. This may sound less than exciting[3] and even in the context of a two-day training event it only rates one slide bullet. But despite this, these tool improvements address a significant real-world need, and are certainly worthy of a blog post or two.

Before we look at the new “Denali” goodness, let’s look at a scenario in pre-“Denali” SSIS today[4]:

  1. You’re editing an Execute SQL task in your package, and realize that you need a variable in which to store the results of the query you’re running.
  2. You exit the task editor, and in the Variables window you create a new variable.
  3. Later on, you’re looking for the variable, and you can’t find it. You frown, scratch your head, and re-create the variable.
  4. When you run your package, you find that although the package (and the Execute SQL task) runs successfully, the variable is never populated with the value from the query.
  5. You get yourself another coffee and settle down for a long troubleshooting session…

Experienced SSIS developers will probably be saying something along the lines of “well, of course, you needed to click on the package Control Flow design surface between steps 1 and 2. Duh!”

Those who are newer to SSIS may be missing the key point in this scenario: When you create a new variable in SSIS, the variable is created at the scope of whatever container or task was selected in the designer. Although this behavior is consistent and documented, it often comes as a surprise, because nobody actually reads the documentation.[5] It also often comes as a frustration, because most of the time variables should be created at the package level in order to be useful.[6]

In SQL Server “Denali” SSIS, all new variables are created at the package scope. This change ensures that the “what the heck” moments we experienced in previous versions of SSIS will no longer occur, and that all new variables will be defined at the most frequently used scope.

What about those situations when you actually do want a variable at a different scope? In previous versions of SSIS, variable scope could not be changed – you needed to delete the old variable and create a new one at the new scope.[7]

In SQL Server “Denali” SSIS, you can move or copy variables between scopes. Odds are you will need this functionality less than you needed it in earlier versions of SSIS (you know, when it wasn’t there) but when you need it, you’ll love it.

And that’s that. As per usual, I wrote two pages when I could have written two sentences (the ones I highlighted in red) but there you have it. The facts are always more meaningful when presented in the context of a story, and hopefully the story helped turn these two bullets into something more than a”yawn” moment. I’m sure you’ll let me know…


[1] In case you’re interested: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syntactic_ambiguity.

[2] Yes, I crack myself up.

[3] And less funny that my ambiguity joke, at least a little.

[4] This is true with SSIS in SQL Server 2005, 2008 and 2008 R2.

[5] Except you. I know you do, I meant everybody else. You know those guys…

[6] One of the “lightweight best practices” I have included in my SSIS presentations over the years is “always right-click on the package design surface and choose Variables from the context menu” because it ensures that the new variable is at the package scope regardless of what task you were working on beforehand.

[7] This functionality does exist in the amazing BIDS Helper add-in, but it was not included in SSIS.

Advertisements

About ssimagine

My name is Matthew Roche, and I am a Senior Program Manager with the SQL Server product group at Microsoft. I work on Master Data Services and Data Quality Services, and have previously worked on SQL Server Integration Services. Although I work for Microsoft and will be posting on technical topics, I want to stress that this is a personal blog, and any opinions posted here are mine and mine alone. I built my career around SQL Server and Microsoft technologies for well over a decade before I joined Microsoft as an employee, and I plan on using this blog to share my personal experience and opinions. They may well be shaped by my experience on the SQL Server team, but they’re still mine, and not that of Microsoft, disclaimer, disclaimer, etc., etc..
This entry was posted in BI, Denali, SSIS, Training. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s